Making Good Choices What Would You Do? Cards

Two Saturday invitations for the same afternoon, and both plans sound great.

40 scenario cards
120 action cards
40 reflection sheets
Print + digital

In the full library, with 69 more on Making Good Choices & Consequences

Task cards, scenario cards, worksheets and more (grades K–8).

Get the free Self-Awareness What Would You Do? Cards

Free account · school email works · See the full library

Same format, free with a free account: Self-Awareness What Would You Do? CardsOpen it →

Grades: 2–5
What you get: 40 scenario cards in five subtopics
Type: What Would You Do? Cards
Use it: Print + digitaldigital = one link, no student logins
Competency: Responsible Decision‑Making
Topic: Making Good Choices & Consequences

About this resource

Two Saturday invitations for the same afternoon, and both plans sound great. These making good choices what would you do scenarios give Grades 2–5 forty decisions that come with time to think: spotting the options, picturing what happens next, weighing want against should and thinking about who else is affected. Students choose from three action cards and explain why, building Responsible Decision-Making one scenario at a time.

What students practice

Noticing when there is a choice to make
Thinking ahead before choosing
Choosing between want and should
Picking between two good options
Considering how a choice affects others

What’s inside

40scenario cards in five subtopics: Spotting That There Is a Choice, Thinking About What Happens Next, Choosing Between “Want” and “Should”, Picking Between Two Good Options and Thinking About Who My Choice Affects

120action cards, three per scenario

40reflection sheets ending in “Your Turn! What Action Would You Take?”

A teacher guide with five ways to use the set; 77 pages

A look inside

The Laundromat Hour: one more hour in the dryer, and you groan, “There’s nothing to do here.” The cards: Look for Options, Ask Dad for Ideas, Slump and Wait.

Grandpa’s Pocket Watchyou want to bring it to show-and-tell. The most helpful card, Bring a Photo, pictures how it could get dropped at school.

One Chapter Leftdinner is called just as you’re about to learn who took the missing map.

Music for the Long Driveyou get to pick the music, and your grandma and baby cousin are in the car too.

How to use these making good choices what would you do cards

Read The Fork in the Path in morning meeting and ask what choice the rider almost missed.

Run a partner debate on Art Club or Swim Team, assigning each pair one action to defend.

Role-play Mango and the Street Fair and pause with Freeze & Reflect before the family leaves.

Use the reflection sheets as homework or in SEL journals, letting students write a choice of their own.

Grade fit

Home holds 17 scenes, the community 13 (a zoo, a fair, a laundromat) and school 10, so most choices happen outside class time, just as they do for elementary students. Grades 2–3 can talk through options aloud; Grades 4–5 can weigh the two-good-options cards in writing as decision making activities.

Digital version

The interactive digital version shares as one link: students answer the think questions (or just read them in the quick format), choose an action card and say why, on any device with no student logins. At the end they download an answer sheet to hand in.

Pairs well with

Making Good Choices Worksheets — Multiple-Choice ScenariosFull library · Worksheets

Making Good Choices Scenario Cards — Printable & DigitalFull library · Scenario Cards

Questions teachers ask

Are these split-second choices or ones with time to think?

Time to think. The scenarios cover spotting options, thinking ahead, want versus should, two good options and who a choice affects, with mild, realistic results.