Ethical Decision-Making Role Play Activity Kit
“Everyone else was doing it.” This ethical decision-making role play kit works on the reasoning behind a line like that, before the moment of choice arrives.
This resource is in the full SEL Resource Library. See what’s included or start with 10 free resources. Have an account? Log in.
About this resource
“Everyone else was doing it.” This ethical decision-making role play kit works on the reasoning behind a line like that, before the moment of choice arrives. Pairs and small groups in Grades 2–5 act out real-life dilemmas that ask them to weigh fairness, honesty and how their choices affect others. It is a Responsible Decision-Making lesson in a set of SEL activities where students commit to a choice and play it through.
What students practice
- Thinking a choice through before acting
- Weighing fairness, honesty and kindness
- Using empathy as a guide in a dilemma
- Reflecting on how different decisions lead to different outcomes
What’s inside
- A teacher guide with a detailed script and a flexible outline: three steps, about 25 minutes
- Ethical Dilemma Scenario Cards: 20 dilemmas, each with three reflection questions
- Role-Playing Character Cards: 12 roles, each with a situation and three “Think About” questions
- Reflection Worksheet (six prompts) and a Fairness and Empathy Checklist (five yes/no questions with space to explain)
- Feedback Cards for noting what went well and one suggestion for growth; 21 pages
A look inside
- Scenario 5: “You accidentally break something in the classroom, but no one saw you.”
- Role-Playing Character Card: “Your group can’t agree on how to finish the project. Some want to rush, while others want to take their time.”
- Fairness and Empathy Checklist: “Could I have made a different choice that was more fair or kind?”
How to use this ethical decision-making role play kit
- Open by asking about a time they had to choose between something easy and something right
- Give pairs or groups a dilemma card and a character card, and have them act out what they would do
- After each scene, ask whether the choice was fair for everyone, how the other person might feel and what else could be tried
- Finish with the reflection worksheet and checklist, and let peers or teachers use the feedback cards
Grade fit
The dilemmas, from a rumor about a classmate to a friend who wants to copy your homework, are written for Grades 2–5. Younger groups can do the role-play aloud, while older ones can write their reflections.
Pairs well with
For more practice with new situations, add Ethical Decision-Making Task Cards or the What Happens Next? kit, more making good choices activities.
Questions teachers ask
How long does the lesson take?
The script is built around three steps and about 25 minutes.
How many dilemmas are included?
20 Ethical Dilemma Scenario Cards, plus 12 Role-Playing Character Cards to add a specific role to a scene.
More for Responsible Decision‑Making
See all in the library →
Every resource, one library.
572 SEL resources for elementary classrooms — printables, digital activities and answer sheets, and every new one we add.
