Conflict Resolution Scenario Cards — Printable & Digital
Conflict resolution is not about getting along perfectly. These conflict resolution scenario cards rehearse the thirty seconds after things go sideways, when students want to escalate or shut down and need other options.
This resource is in the full SEL Resource Library. See what’s included or start with 10 free resources. Have an account? Log in.
About this resource
Conflict resolution is not about getting along perfectly. These conflict resolution scenario cards rehearse the thirty seconds after things go sideways, when students want to escalate or shut down and need other options. Written for Grades 2–6, the 60 everyday disagreements build Relationship Skills and Social Awareness.
What students practice
- Staying calm when a disagreement starts
- Seeing why the other person acted that way
- Saying what they need
- Standing up for themselves without escalating
- Finding a way forward together
What’s inside
- 60 disagreements in five themes: misunderstandings between friends, sharing and personal space, group work and fairness, games, rules and competition, and standing up and working it out
- 60 open-ended scenario cards, 4 per page, each with the prompt “What can you do?”
- 60 guided scenario cards: the same scenarios, each with 3 questions on both sides of the conflict and working toward resolution
- 120 journal pages, one open-ended and one guided page per scenario, for written reflection and peer mediation preparation
- 158 pages in all
A look inside
- The Unanswered Message: “You waved at your friend in the hallway, but they didn’t wave back.”
- The Group Secret: “You overhear your friend whispering to others and laughing, but they stop talking when you walk over.”
- The Wandering Elbows: “While working on a shared table, your classmate’s papers and arms keep sliding into your space.”
How to use these conflict resolution scenario cards
- SEL lessons on conflict resolution, communication and empathy
- Peer mediation training and restorative circles
- A morning meeting after a classroom or recess conflict
- Writing centers and behavior journals using the journal pages
- Use them as what would you do scenarios, with students answering the prompt “What can you do?”
Grade fit
Scenes like The Marker Mix-Up and The Shared Crayons work for second graders, while The Changed Group Chat and The Missed “Sorry” give older students more to untangle. That spread suits Grades 2–6.
Digital version
The printable and digital scenario cards work together: share one link, pick the open-ended or guided format, and students respond on any device with no student logins. At the end they download an answer sheet to hand in.
Pairs well with
Add Conflict Resolution Task Cards for shorter, leveled prompts on the same skill, or Conflict Resolution Conversation Cards for whole-class talk.
Questions teachers ask
What do the guided questions ask?
They ask what might be going on, why the other person acted that way, and how to find a way forward.
Are the scenarios tests?
No. They are rehearsal: students practice what they would say and do before a real conflict.
More for Relationship Skills
See all in the library →
Every resource, one library.
572 SEL resources for elementary classrooms — printables, digital activities and answer sheets, and every new one we add.
